Jose Echenique wrote:How does it compare with the Gardiner? That´s still my favorite.mcq wrote:This is simply magical. Philippe Herreweghe's recent version of Haydn's Die Jahreszeiten is just breathtaking in the sense of life-affirming wonder that it evokes. Grace and beauty harnessed with the refined delicacy that we expect from this master conductor. Very highly recommended.
It's hard to select one version as "the best". I love the versions by Gardiner, Harnoncourt (DHM) and Jacobs and each of these conductors bring their own interpretative touches and individual style to the piece. Herreweghe imbues the piece with a pastoral serenity, a tranquil delicacy and a kind of hushed grandeur whereas Gardiner's version is more vibrant and earthy and visceral. (It's always a pleasure to hear Anthony Rolfe Johnson in his recordings with Gardiner.) Personally, I wouldn't want to be without either version. I'm also very interested in Harnoncourt's new version on DVD as well which was recorded at the 2013 Salzburg Festival and I'm tempted by Bruno Weil on Ars Produktion.

