Tír Na HiFi

DonKC wrote:The Choral Fantasy is another wonderful Beethoven work overshadowed by his towering masterpieces, this time the Symphony # 9.

That LvB's Symphonic output represents a towering achievement of Western Civilization's artistic expression, is incontrovertible.

I nevertheless, never cease to be amazed by the propensity of some forum members for collecting numerous versions of said masterpieces, together with the air time they are given... ;-)

DonKC wrote:The Choral Fantasy is another wonderful Beethoven work overshadowed by his towering masterpieces, this time the Symphony # 9.

Agreed Don!

Jared wrote:
That LvB's Symphonic output represents a towering achievement of Western Civilization's artistic expression, is incontrovertible.

I nevertheless, never cease to be amazed by the propensity of some forum members for collecting numerous versions of said masterpieces, together with the air time they are given... ;-)

I suppose that you could put me at about top of that list Jared LOL!! Not only have I listened to a number of the individual symphonies lately but I have just completed listening to this set yesterday....

Today....

fergus wrote:

Jared wrote:
That LvB's Symphonic output represents a towering achievement of Western Civilization's artistic expression, is incontrovertible.

I nevertheless, never cease to be amazed by the propensity of some forum members for collecting numerous versions of said masterpieces, together with the air time they are given... ;-)

I suppose that you could put me at about top of that list Jared LOL!!

Me too, a large amount of what you fancy does you good.

Jared wrote: That LvB's Symphonic output represents a towering achievement of Western Civilization's artistic expression, is incontrovertible.

I nevertheless, never cease to be amazed by the propensity of some forum members for collecting numerous versions of said masterpieces, together with the air time they are given... ;-)

Another thing to bear in mind Jared is that I use the Beethoven symphonies as a sounding board, literally. If there is a new orchestra and/or conductor that I might be interested in checking out in detail I always look to see if the have a LvB symphonic cycle credited to them and if so I will buy it to see how they handle this music. Because I am very familiar with the music I do not concentrate on it but rather can focus on the interpretation and the playing etc.

fergus wrote:

Jared wrote: That LvB's Symphonic output represents a towering achievement of Western Civilization's artistic expression, is incontrovertible.

I nevertheless, never cease to be amazed by the propensity of some forum members for collecting numerous versions of said masterpieces, together with the air time they are given... ;-)

Another thing to bear in mind Jared is that I use the Beethoven symphonies as a sounding board, literally. If there is a new orchestra and/or conductor that I might be interested in checking out in detail I always look to see if the have a LvB symphonic cycle credited to them and if so I will buy it to see how they handle this music. Because I am very familiar with the music I do not concentrate on it but rather can focus on the interpretation and the playing etc.

that's an interesting way of looking at things, Fergus.

I seam to have touched a nerve over my comments however, which I didn't mean to... the ;-) at the end of my sentence suggests that it was meant in a light-hearted way and not as a criticism. I only really have a maximum of three versions of anything (very few things actually), two of works I like and one of everything else, so I probably would never benefit from comparative listening in the same way you can.

Jared wrote:

fergus wrote:

Jared wrote: That LvB's Symphonic output represents a towering achievement of Western Civilization's artistic expression, is incontrovertible.

I nevertheless, never cease to be amazed by the propensity of some forum members for collecting numerous versions of said masterpieces, together with the air time they are given... ;-)

Another thing to bear in mind Jared is that I use the Beethoven symphonies as a sounding board, literally. If there is a new orchestra and/or conductor that I might be interested in checking out in detail I always look to see if the have a LvB symphonic cycle credited to them and if so I will buy it to see how they handle this music. Because I am very familiar with the music I do not concentrate on it but rather can focus on the interpretation and the playing etc.

that's an interesting way of looking at things, Fergus.

I seam to have touched a nerve over my comments however, which I didn't mean to... the ;-) at the end of my sentence suggests that it was meant in a light-hearted way and not as a criticism. I only really have a maximum of three versions of anything (very few things actually), two of works I like and one of everything else, so I probably would never benefit from comparative listening in the same way you can.

Not in my case, you didn't, I doubt very much if you upset young Fergus either.

Jared wrote:I seam to have touched a nerve over my comments however, which I didn't mean to... the ;-) at the end of my sentence suggests that it was meant in a light-hearted way and not as a criticism. I only really have a maximum of three versions of anything (very few things actually), two of works I like and one of everything else, so I probably would never benefit from comparative listening in the same way you can.

Not in my case, you didn't, I doubt very much if you upset young Fergus either.