
Let´s start Verdi Year with one of his, or anyones, greatest operas. In this sad times when Verdi and Wagner voices seem to have vanished, this live Otello from 1987 is a good reminder that not that long ago there were truly great voices that made the composer proud. Plácido Domingo may not have had the tenore drammatico quality of a Giovanni Martinelli, Mario del Monaco or Jon Vickers, but his slightly more lyrical voice had the dark color essential for the role, and his incomparable artistry and musicianship certainly fulfilled the role´s needs. Anna Tomowa-Sintow, one of Karajan´s favorite sopranos (mine too!) had a creamy but powerful lirico-spinto, ideal for Desdemona. Besides singing like an angel she also brings dignity to the role, many other sopranos play/sing the role like a dumb blonde, but not the great Tomowa-Sintow. Verdi baritones are as rare these days as a tyrannosaurus rex. Renato Bruson was the genuine article, his gorgeous, aristocratic voice was a thing of rare beauty, and he can play a nasty guy too.
Zubin Mehta conducts very well, of course Claudio Abbado or Riccardo Muti would have been preferable, but Mehta rises to the challenge of conducting this fabulous cast.
The ORF sound is clean and well defined. Compared to this, the most recent recording of Otello, Colin Davis with the LSO in the LSO label is a joke. The tenor, Simon O´Neill, sounds 3 sizes too small for the role (he was a late replacement for an indisposed tenor, but then why release the recording?). Only the Iago, the bass-baritone Gerald Finley is actually acceptable, though he is not a Verdi singer by nature, certainly not one to compete with Renato Bruson.