Tír Na HiFi

Jared wrote: Simply not good enough Mr Fergus... that's rampant, naked favouritism...

LOL!!!

For me one of the acid tests of a conductor is how they get on with a Beethoven cycle. However Walter is a firm favourite with me so this was not an issue in this case; I simply did not have a Beethoven cycle by him.

There are at least two more Beethoven cycles on the List yet to be purshased!

Stravinsky - Symphonies of Wind instruments & La Sacre du Printemps (Kent Nagano, London Symphony Orchestra, Virgin Classics)

fergus wrote:

Jared wrote: Simply not good enough Mr Fergus... that's rampant, naked favouritism...

LOL!!!

For me one of the acid tests of a conductor is how they get on with a Beethoven cycle. However Walter is a firm favourite with me so this was not an issue in this case; I simply did not have a Beethoven cycle by him.

There are at least two more Beethoven cycles on the List yet to be purshased!

I agree with your arguments there Fergus. Which cycles are there still left for you to purchase?

Saint-Saens - Piano Concerto No.2 (Emil Gilels/Andre Cluytens, Orchestre de la Societe des Concerts du Conservatoire, EMI)

bombasticDarren wrote:Stravinsky - Symphonies of Wind instruments & La Sacre du Printemps (Kent Nagano, London Symphony Orchestra, Virgin Classics)

How did you get on with that one Darren? Nagano is not a conductor that I am familiar with.

bombasticDarren wrote:

fergus wrote:

Jared wrote: Simply not good enough Mr Fergus... that's rampant, naked favouritism...

LOL!!!

For me one of the acid tests of a conductor is how they get on with a Beethoven cycle. However Walter is a firm favourite with me so this was not an issue in this case; I simply did not have a Beethoven cycle by him.

There are at least two more Beethoven cycles on the List yet to be purshased!

I agree with your arguments there Fergus. Which cycles are there still left for you to purchase?

I will definitely buy the Furtwangler set Darren and I am considering the Chailly cycle. I have heard it but I am not fully convinced by it....I will see.

I have finally completed my first full listen of the Ring with Gotterdammerung....





This is a very lyrical and very appealing work and there are some really wonderful pieces of music in this opera.

fergus wrote:

bombasticDarren wrote:

fergus wrote: LOL!!!

For me one of the acid tests of a conductor is how they get on with a Beethoven cycle. However Walter is a firm favourite with me so this was not an issue in this case; I simply did not have a Beethoven cycle by him.

There are at least two more Beethoven cycles on the List yet to be purshased!

I agree with your arguments there Fergus. Which cycles are there still left for you to purchase?

I will definitely buy the Furtwangler set Darren and I am considering the Chailly cycle. I have heard it but I am not fully convinced by it....I will see.

Hi Fergus, have you given any consideration to getting the Vänskä/Minnesota Orchestra cycle? It is very good. I will give the Chailly a miss, I have heard some of it and it doesn't move me. I will get the Walter & Furtwangler sets but I won't join you on your Beethoven quest at this time, enjoy.

I wasn´t too happy with the Chailly either Seán, and feel very frustrated because I really wanted a top modern cycle with the great Gewandhaus Orchestra, but it was not to be.