Re: What are you listening to?
Posted: Sun May 13, 2012 12:02 pm
Following my discussion yesterday with Seán I took out and listened to this CD this morning....
The Magnificat is well played and sung if a little long and slightly laboured in places. That is not a criticism just an observation on interpretation. Rilling’s touch is light here instrumentally and there is a certain element of volubility that is appealing as a representation of that era of Bach presentation. I kept this version having sold on other Rilling Bach performances so I obviously like it. I wonder Seán have you done a direct comparison between the presentation styles of the other major work on this CD i.e. Vivaldi’s Gloria. Different composers and works I know but Vivaldi and Bach are almost exact contemporaries and the two works are not very dissimilar in tone and texture but I think are handled differently. Malgoire, whom you know I also admire, has a lighter touch overall which brings sparkle to the music but still retains the solemn integrity of the work. Interestingly the Vivaldi Gloria was recorded three years before the Bach Magnificat.
These things are always a matter subjective interpretation and, fortunately, everyone is different and hears things differently. I have spoken to so many people over the years that have been put off the music of JS Bach by (in my opinion) poor performances and interpretation which is very unfortunate. The same thing happened to me with the symphonic music of Brahms so I understand how important it is to get what is right for your ear. So, presentation and interpretation are critical in classical music as they can make or break a work or composer for the unsuspecting listener.
OK I will get off my soap box and let you all relax and enjoy the rest of your Sunday!!!
This is a lovely CD by the way and for those that enjoy this genre of music is available quite cheaply (around £2.00 + p+p used) and does come recommended.
The Magnificat is well played and sung if a little long and slightly laboured in places. That is not a criticism just an observation on interpretation. Rilling’s touch is light here instrumentally and there is a certain element of volubility that is appealing as a representation of that era of Bach presentation. I kept this version having sold on other Rilling Bach performances so I obviously like it. I wonder Seán have you done a direct comparison between the presentation styles of the other major work on this CD i.e. Vivaldi’s Gloria. Different composers and works I know but Vivaldi and Bach are almost exact contemporaries and the two works are not very dissimilar in tone and texture but I think are handled differently. Malgoire, whom you know I also admire, has a lighter touch overall which brings sparkle to the music but still retains the solemn integrity of the work. Interestingly the Vivaldi Gloria was recorded three years before the Bach Magnificat.
These things are always a matter subjective interpretation and, fortunately, everyone is different and hears things differently. I have spoken to so many people over the years that have been put off the music of JS Bach by (in my opinion) poor performances and interpretation which is very unfortunate. The same thing happened to me with the symphonic music of Brahms so I understand how important it is to get what is right for your ear. So, presentation and interpretation are critical in classical music as they can make or break a work or composer for the unsuspecting listener.
OK I will get off my soap box and let you all relax and enjoy the rest of your Sunday!!!
This is a lovely CD by the way and for those that enjoy this genre of music is available quite cheaply (around £2.00 + p+p used) and does come recommended.
