Tír Na HiFi

Pyotr Liyich Tchaikovsky
Piano Concerto No's 1 & 2
New Philharmonia Orchestra
Emil Gilels piano
Lorin Maazel - conducting.
[Recorded in 1972]

This is a great set, the performance of the Second Symphony is hugely enjoyable.

If you like piano concertos, then this is definitely one for you.

^^ no two ways about it, that's a mighty tempting boxset...

meantime... about the 7th listen in 3 days:



and the 5th listen in 2 days:



both superb recordings...

Seán wrote:

fergus wrote:

Jared wrote: incidentally, I'll shortly be joining you in the same traversal... I own the above set, and have recently purchased the Budapest's re-release on Sony..

Good, we can compare notes as I am just starting off on something of an oddyssey myself with the Beethoven String Quartets!

Well done Jared, you won't be disappointed. Fergus, have you got a copy of the set?

No, Seán, I have just recently purchased the Végh cycle and I have set my sights on the Takács cycle next.

Jared wrote:^^ not heard the Karajan Missa, although I have a real soft spot for the Klemperer... generally though, I prefer HIP in these pieces..

So do I jared but I had read good things about the von Karajan version over the years. It is a powerful rendition and much more devotional and less dramatic than I was expecting!

There has been some talk here lately of JS Bach's Motets so I listened to this on vinyl; JS Bach Motets BWV 225, 227 & 229....





There is nothing particularly remarkable about the performances on this recording other than the fact that the choir sing unaccompanied by either an organ or any other instrumentation. It is an interesting take on JSB’s music. BWV229 was quite attractive.

fergus wrote:Fergus, have you got a copy of the [Budapest] set[/color]?

No, Seán, I have just recently purchased the Végh cycle and I have set my sights on the Takács cycle next.[/quote]
Where did you get the Végh set? I have been looking for a copy of it.

Seán wrote: Where did you get the Végh set? I have been looking for a copy of it.

From an Amazon market place seller....it took me over one year to find one at a good price; I eventually paid £40 fo it used in pristine condition and I have seen it for sale for up to £125!!

Mozart – Violin Concertos 4 & 5....



I think that these were fine performances in themselves but neither are truly Mozartians imho. For true Mozart playing the touch needs to be delicate and a certain phrasing is required along with certain lilt required in the playing. An enjoyable set nonetheless.

On vinyl: Schubert – The Trout Quintet....