Page 163 of 804
Re: MQN
Posted: Wed Jan 08, 2014 6:45 pm
by nige2000
ok JC not completely nutz
sounds really good, good flow and focus
surely an improvement on the original
still lacks the detail/resolution of the 2.7X MQn'S, which is hard to be without once heard
Whats the proaudio settings for these?
Re: MQN
Posted: Wed Jan 08, 2014 8:34 pm
by Aleg
nige2000 wrote:
ok JC not completely nutz
sounds really good, good flow and focus
surely an improvement on the original
still lacks the detail/resolution of the 2.7X MQn'S, which is hard to be without once heard
Whats the proaudio settings for these?
Nigel
I agree on the lack of detail, the 2.7x can show more of the microdynamics of acoustic instruments than this version.
It doesn't sound bad, but just not as good as the more recent mqn versions.
What you call good focus, I would call lack of soundstage. All the sound is so much dead centered it is almost mono. Something I don't like at all and is very unnatural when you know what the instrumental setup is on stage. Instruments right on top of each other or guitar right on top of the vocals instead of just off to the side.
I didn't compare it to the original so don't know what the actual improvement is this mod brings, but I'm not that interested as it doesn't match up with the newest versions.
Cheers
Aleg
Re: MQN
Posted: Wed Jan 08, 2014 10:04 pm
by sbgk
JC
which version was it and why choose that one over a load/play version ?
Can these settings be used during the build ?
Re: MQN
Posted: Wed Jan 08, 2014 11:58 pm
by nige2000
Aleg wrote:
I didn't compare it to the original so don't know what the actual improvement is this mod brings, but I'm not that interested as it doesn't match up with the newest versions.
i didnt compare it against the original either but old 2.2 wasnt that good, regardless your right its not up there with the last few MQn's
only getting back to the timer resolution thing, will this work
http://www.lucashale.com/timer-resolution/
free one seems to be fully functional
seems to add something good but small
Re: MQN
Posted: Thu Jan 09, 2014 12:42 am
by sbgk
nige2000 wrote:Aleg wrote:
I didn't compare it to the original so don't know what the actual improvement is this mod brings, but I'm not that interested as it doesn't match up with the newest versions.
i didnt compare it against the original either but old 2.2 wasnt that good, regardless your right its not up there with the last few MQn's
only getting back to the timer resolution thing, will this work
http://www.lucashale.com/timer-resolution/
free one seems to be fully functional
seems to add something good but small
I used to use that, but am not convinced that increasing the timer frequency does anything except add noise. In win 8 there is a setting I can use so that only MQn gets an increase in system timer frequency I think, have tried that with the same results - an increase in digital noise. Running google chrome sets it to 1ms.
Just tried daphile, but am not convinced, quite a strident sound which was disappointing. Nice idea though.
Re: MQN
Posted: Thu Jan 09, 2014 12:55 am
by nige2000
thought MQn is in existence cause these other players weren't up to the task?
Re: MQN
Posted: Thu Jan 09, 2014 2:47 am
by jesuscheung
sbgk wrote:JC
which version was it and why choose that one over a load/play version ?
Can these settings be used during the build ?
the version is mqn.exe2.2.
because old versions tend to improve/change a lot with PE mod. new versions less so. also too many new versions
when you compile mqn, there should be settings regarding SizeOfStackReserve, SizeOfStackCommit, SizeOfHeapReserve, SizeOfHeapCommit.
also changed MajorLinkerVersion to 0A from... forgot...
interesting note: there is "DefaultRpcStackSize" in the registry. it is same stack settings as above, which you can modify for services like AudioSrv. affects SQ too. haven't time to figure out best value hehe
Re: MQN
Posted: Thu Jan 09, 2014 3:04 am
by jesuscheung
Aleg wrote:
What you call good focus, I would call lack of soundstage. All the sound is so much dead centered it is almost mono. Something I don't like at all and is very unnatural when you know what the instrumental setup is on stage. Instruments right on top of each other or guitar right on top of the vocals instead of just off to the side.
Aleg, don't fall in love with soundstage you hear on a windows setup. i doubt it is any correct. i can easily tell you 20 things (outside of mqn) that affect soundstage on windows. you cannot be sure the external factors have correct influence on soundstage. for example, your clockrate whatever it is (23220?!), already distorts soundstage coz it is not totally in syn between mqn and your dac hehe
if you have spent sometimes tweaking rather than using convenience audiophile script, you will realize soundstage is very unstable on windows.
i know your speakers can produce correct soundstage. doesn't mean it can correct incorrect soundstage. incorrect soundstage is worse than no soundstage in my opinion.
people seem easily to confuse 3D effects with natural 3D.
Re: MQN
Posted: Thu Jan 09, 2014 6:32 am
by Aleg
nige2000 wrote:Aleg wrote:
I didn't compare it to the original so don't know what the actual improvement is this mod brings, but I'm not that interested as it doesn't match up with the newest versions.
i didnt compare it against the original either but old 2.2 wasnt that good, regardless your right its not up there with the last few MQn's
only getting back to the timer resolution thing, will this work
http://www.lucashale.com/timer-resolution/
free one seems to be fully functional
seems to add something good but small
Nige
The 'problem' with this version is it will only set the maximum resolution of 0.5 ms and no intermediairy values. Pushing your machine to the limit may not be a good idea and may be responsible for the digital noise Gordon hears?
I forgot all about my offer just before my mobo-crash.
This weekend I will send you the source code and compile instruction for a version that can set intermediairy values on a temporary basis and one that installs as a service and works on a permanent basis.
I feel you need to set the timerresolution in balance with your driver buffersize.
I use 2ms for both and think it sounds very good that way.
Cheers
Aleg
Re: MQN
Posted: Thu Jan 09, 2014 6:49 am
by Aleg
jesuscheung wrote:Aleg wrote:
What you call good focus, I would call lack of soundstage. All the sound is so much dead centered it is almost mono. Something I don't like at all and is very unnatural when you know what the instrumental setup is on stage. Instruments right on top of each other or guitar right on top of the vocals instead of just off to the side.
Aleg, don't fall in love with soundstage you hear on a windows setup. i doubt it is any correct. i can easily tell you 20 things (outside of mqn) that affect soundstage on windows. you cannot be sure the external factors have correct influence on soundstage. for example, your clockrate whatever it is (23220?!), already distorts soundstage coz it is not totally in syn between mqn and your dac hehe
if you have spent sometimes tweaking rather than using convenience audiophile script, you will realize soundstage is very unstable on windows.
i know your speakers can produce correct soundstage. doesn't mean it can correct incorrect soundstage. incorrect soundstage is worse than no soundstage in my opinion.
people seem easily to confuse 3D effects with natural 3D.
JC
I'm not going for a 'big soundstage' at all nor just for the sake of it.
I want to have it sound natural. I'm in this case not speaking about 3D soundstage, so not depth, but just spread so 2D.
When I listen to a solo vocal with guitar, I know the guitarist sits just about a meter and a half to the left of the vocalist on stage. I don't want to hear to guitarist on top of the vocal, but about 1 meter and a half to the left.
When I listen to a string quartet I want to hear the first violinist to the left, the cello to the right and second violinist and viola in the middle of the soundstage, not all on top of each other.
I'm not looking to exagerate any of these effects but I want them to be present in a natural way that is there when I hear it live.
BTW Nowadays I listen with DRC-music which corrects also phase issues and does present the music from my speakers in a very detailed and natural sounding way. Now it is just the playback itself that needs to be correct.
Cheers
Aleg