Philppe Herreweghe's recording of the Sabbato Sancto Responoria (on Harmonia Mundi) are superior to the Tallis performances, which, whilst good, are a little dry in comparison.Diapason wrote:Yes indeed, talking about that Gesualdo disc. Turned it off and put on some Simon and Garfunkel instead!Jared wrote:are you referring to the Gesualdo, Simon?Diapason wrote:You've persuaded me to do the same, Fergus. Truthfully, I'm not getting much out of it, for some reason this music just doesn't float my boat. Strange really, you'd think it would be right up my street.
I also love La Venexiana's performances of the Fourth and Fifth Books of the madrigals (available on Glossa) which maintain the high standards they set in their Monteverdi recordings.
William Christie has also recorded a selection of the madrigals for HM but he - unwisely in my opinion - added musical accompaniments which strip the music somewhat of the pared-down intensity of a truly accapella setting.
For the past few weeks I've been totally absorbed in Volumes 2 and 3 of Harry van der Kamp's career-defining Sweelinck Monument (recorded with his Gesualdo Consort Amsterdam and available on Glossa). Volume 2 (a 2-CD set ) concentrates on the 1619 collection of motets entitled Cantiones Sacrae and Volume 3 (a 12-CD set) concentrates on what was Sweelinck's magnum opus of the musical rendering of the Psalms from the Book of David. This is immensely rewarding music, beautifully performed by a dedicated set of musicians and very highly recommended.