JAW wrote:This one was driving me nutz!!! Once again, lost without the clue!
BTW, You're right about Live in Gdansk, Great versions of Fat Old Sun and Echoes, Showcasing what a fine guitar player Dave Gilmour is.
Well done J!! Sorry for driving you nuts though but at least the clue softened the nuts a little
bit :-)). Relieved to hear you like Gdansk as I completely forgot about 'Remember that Night' DVD!!! I still haven't watched it properly;Assuming you already have it, how does it compare to Gdansk?
Last edited by cybot on Thu Apr 29, 2010 1:44 pm, edited 1 time in total.
JAW wrote:This one was driving me nutz!!! Once again, lost without the clue!
BTW, You're right about Live in Gdansk, Great versions of Fat Old Sun and Echoes, Showcasing what a fine guitar player Dave Gilmour is.
Well done J!! Sorry for driving you nuts though but at least the clue softened the nuts a little
bit :-)). Relieved to hear you like Gdansk as I completely forgot about 'Remember that Night' DVD!!! I still haven't watched it properly;Assuming you already have it, how does it compare to
Gdansk?
Now you're asking the question! Ok, my cd player (Arcam CD33) is far better sonically than the dvd player (DV89), but for live stuff there's something about the involvement of surround sound that's more engaging. But the nuances are there on the cd that aren't on the dvd. I wonder about the five disc vinyl version, though, ie Echoes is 25 minutes long. Is this not approaching the limits of a vinyl side?
JAW wrote:
Now you're asking the question! Ok, my cd player (Arcam CD33) is far better sonically than the dvd player (DV89), but for live stuff there's something about the involvement of surround sound that's more engaging. But the nuances are there on the cd that aren't on the dvd. I wonder about the five disc vinyl version, though, ie Echoes is 25 minutes long. Is this not approaching the limits of a vinyl side?
It probably is J, but it sounds fine, honestly.. Do you remember 'A Plague of Lighthouse Keepers' by VDGG? I'm sure it's nearly 31 minutes long...but I could be wrong.Really, some of the long sided stuff has no right to sound ok but some seem to get away with it....just :-))
